Edited by Lisa Cassidy and Mianna Lotz, Philosophies of Adoption: Perspectives and Reflections explores contemporary philosophical analysis of adoption, providing insight into new and underexplored topics in the field. Three scholarly developments are central to the emerging philosophical discourse on adoption explored in this volume: a problematizing of the adoption triangle or triad, a critique of the so-called bio-normative family, and an attention to specific issues in transracial and First Nations adoption. The books contributors expand on all three of these areas by addressing a range of questionsHow does being adopted shape self-knowledge and identity? What challenges arise at the intersection of race and adoption? What can be learned about epistemic justice, identity, and belonging from transracial adoption? What are the narratives told about adoption?to show how current conditions and lived adoptee experiences give new shape, meaning, and importance to philosophical thinking about adoption. Showcasing a diversity of styles and standpoints, and organized into three core themessituating adoption, knowing adoption, and telling adoptionthis book grapples with the adoption experience, historical and recent developments in adoption practice, and emerging directions in philosophical scholarship.
This book explores the philosophical analysis of adoption by providing insight into the emerging and underexplored topics within the implications and realities of adoption. Showcasing a range of styles, this book provides first-hand accounts of adult-adoptees through diverse standpoints, voices, perspectives, and relationships to adoption.
Recenzijos
"This lovely collection complements and enriches contemporary philosophical debates about adoption. It engages with the ethical, epistemological, social, and political implications of adoption, and does so with what is in my view a welcome emphasis on the experiences of adult adoptees. Individually, the papers are sophisticated and insightful; collectively they mark an important step forward in our thinking about the historical, personal, and normative dimensions of adoption." -- Andrew Botterell, University of Western Ontario
Introduction
Lisa Cassidy and Mianna Lotz
Part I: Situating Adoption: Histories, Contexts, Boundaries
Chapter 1: Adoption, Race, and Rescue: Transracial Adoption and Lesbian/Gay
Ascendency to Whiteness
Bonnie Mann
Chapter 2: Racist Structures of American Indian Interracial Adoption
Susan Devan Harness
Chapter 3: Unsettling Adoption: Rethinking Parenting in the Shadow of
Colonialism
Mianna Lotz, Colin Macleod, and Taylor-Jai Mcalister
Part II: Knowing Adoption: Epistemic Justice and Injustice
Chapter 4: Adopting Silence: On Adoptee Disenfranchisement and Epistemic
Injustice
Ryan Gustafsson and Michele Merritt
Chapter 5: Adoption Stories and Epistemic Neglect
Cara OConnor
Chapter 6: Racial Belonging and Identity: Impacts on Transracial Adoptees
Epistemic and Moral Agency
Nabina Liebow and Ryan Gustafsson
Part III: Telling Adoption: The Stories We Tell
Chapter 7: Heavy with Child: Infertile Attachments, Existential Racism, and
Geneticism
Frances Latchford
Chapter 8: Adoption in New Media: Changing the Narrative?
Lisa Cassidy
Chapter 9: Excerpt from The Girl I Am, Was, and Never Will Be: A Speculative
Memoir of Transracial Adoption
Shannon Gibney
Chapter 10: Its So Very Layered: In Conversation with Shannon Gibney
Shannon Gibney, Lisa Cassidy, and Mianna Lotz
Lisa Cassidy is associate professor of philosophy at Ramapo College.
Mianna Lotz is associate professor of philosophy at Macquarie University.